Friday, January 21, 2022

Morality and History: The Elusive Search For "The Good Guys"

 


 The triumph of Union forces over the collapsed Confederacy is typically treated as a quintessential example of the existence of "good guys" in history. 
 
Of course, the end of slavery constitutes a moral advance, but we shouldn't kid ourselves about there being any "good guys" in the story.
 
After all, the "good" Union trafficked in black flesh for nearly a century, effected a compromise with defeated slaveholders that allowed them to restore near-slavery for almost another century (the so-called Black codes criminalizing African-American life are in effect to this day), finished off the genocide against dozens of indigenous peoples (the "winning" of the West), slaughtered a couple hundred thousand Filipinos in the name of white supremacy, imposed starvation and chaos on Germany well after WWI "peace" had been declared (paving the way for Hitler and the Nazis), incinerated Tokyo with fire-bombs even more thoroughly than it obliterated Hiroshima and Nagasaki with atom bombs, then spread neo-Nazi clone states throughout the "free" world singing the glories of capital accumulation for the few. To this day, there's not a right-wing dictatorship we don't love. 
 
This is the group claiming the moral high ground.


No comments: