"Our idea is that Labor needs not to combat but to command Capital."
-----New York Tribune, 1860
A wave of democratic socialists speaking the menacing language of sharing, caring, and reciprocity has reared its ugly head and ridden an anti-Trump wave to the halls of Congress. An embattled GOP must now figure out how to beat back its worst nightmare: an array of increasingly popular policies designed to stop wholesale slaughter in the Middle East and bring affordable medical care, child care, housing, and university education to all as a matter of right.
The emergence of this "problem" is only partially a response to Donald Trump. At a deeper level it is part of an effort to put labor in power that extends back to Reconstruction (1865-1877), where it was partially achieved, albeit only temporarily, and only in the South. That effort was crushed by an alliance of Northern capital and Southern planters that unleashed waves of paramilitary terror against recently freed slaves to implement a system of slavery without chattel that lasted into the civil rights era.*
Meanwhile, in the North, robber baron savagery sowed the seeds of a socialist rebellion that emerged in force the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when a dizzying spate of corporate mergers catapulted a few hundred firms into control of more than forty percent of the industrial capital of the country. "Free" labor then enjoyed the unparalleled liberty to prostitute itself to rising monopoly power or die on the streets begging for charity. Government help was unheard of at the time.
By 1905, labor's finest leaders had had enough of the capitalist cycle of boom, bust, panic, and collapse that left workers in perpetual misery. On June 27 Big Bill Haywood lumbered onto the platform at Brand's Hall in Chicago, gaveled the podium with a piece of loose board, and called the assembly to order. Flanked by socialist Eugene Debs, labor firebrand Mother Jones, and African-American anarchist Lucy Parsons, he announced the birth of the Industrial Workers of the World, a union of native-born radicals whose capacity for militant solidarity was and remains unmatched in U.S. history.
Haywood told the two hundred plus delegates crammed into the hot, overcrowded hall that they were "the Continental Congress of the working class," adding that "the aims and objects of this organization should be to put the working class in possession of the economic power, the means of life, in control of production and distribution, without regard to capitalist masters." This ambition was to be fulfilled, not by violent seizure of state power, but by paralyzing big business with a series of general strikes, culminating in direct workers' control of all industries.
Haywood was one of the most popular labor leaders in the country at the time. A child of the West, he was recognized on the
streets of New York the way a star athlete might be today. Adored by women and instinctively obeyed by men, he possessed the manners of a gentleman, packed a
revolver, and cried like a baby when reciting poetry. But from the podium he delivered thunderous orations that ignited crowds of workers like a wick in a
powder keg.
“Eight hours of work, eight hours of play,
eight hours of sleep, EIGHT DOLLARS A DAY!”
The brutality of wage work had taught Haywood of
injustice early and converted him to socialism. His first boss whipped
him when he was only twelve, and the same year he witnessed a black man
surrendered to the tender mercies of a lynch mob. Three years later he
was a Nevada miner doing a “man’s work for a boy’s pay,” breaking the
loneliness of Eagle Canyon reading Darwin, Marx, Burns, Voltaire, Byron,
and Shakespeare. An older miner’s explanation of the class struggle
capped his education, though the lesson didn’t sink in firmly until the
Haymarket anarchists were hung two years later (1887).
After that, Haywood saw scores of men poisoned at Utah’s Brooklyn lead mine, watched a friend’s head crushed against an air drill by a slab of falling rock, and had his own right hand smashed between a descending car and the side of the shaft at Iowa’s Silver City mine. “I’ve never read Marx’s Capital,” he liked to say, “but I have the marks of capital all over me.” Of the class warfare that made such disfigurement routine, he said: “[The] barbarous gold barons do not find the gold, they do not mine the gold, they do not mill the gold, but by some weird alchemy all the gold belongs to them.”
Such ideas were common currency on the socialist left at the time, leaving a residue just beneath the surface of American political life that is being rediscovered today.
A particularly deserving candidate for rediscovery is Haywood's fellow IWW leader Vincent Saint John. Son of a pony express rider, he was, variously, a delivery boy, a farm hand, a tinner, a printer, an upholsterer, a prospecter, a miner, and a militant unionist. With a graduate degree from the school of hard knocks his only creed was action.
In the 1890s he had ruined his lungs rescuing dozens of men from a
smoke-filled mine in Telluride. In 1901, his men rewarded him with the
presidency of the Telluride miners’ union at the tender age of 25. St.
John promptly armed them with 250 rifles and 50,000 rounds of
ammunition, which they used to ambush scabs from behind boulders and
trees and shoot their way into possession of the mines like the Minutemen of old.
“The air smelled clean in his presence,” recalled
one of St. John's men, who nicknamed him “the Saint” in honor of his
incorruptibility. The mine owners, on the other hand, grown fat on the impoverishment of labor, called him a
dynamiter, a gunman,
and a dangerous agitator—and always kept a price on his head.
In 1906, St. John found himself at the center of a brutal
labor struggle in Goldfield, Nevada, the biggest, busiest, richest gold
camp in the world. Crowded with dance halls, saloons, and gambling
houses, it was a boom town swarming with claim jumpers, fortune hunters,
and gamblers, all drawn to the gold like children to candy from every
district in the West.
St. John recruited 20,000 local workers for the I.W.W., including miners, dishwashers, engineers, stenographers, teamsters, clerks, newsboys, croupiers, maids, and prostitutes. He established the eight-hour day, guaranteed a minimum daily wage of $4.50 for all, and abolished individual begging for jobs. Any employer wishing to hire workers had to come and negotiate with the union committees. A company detective explained to the Rocky Mountain News that the I.W.W. leader posed an intolerable threat to high society wherever he went: “St. John has given the mine owners of Colorado more trouble in the past years than twenty other men up there. If left undisturbed, he would have the entire district organized in another year.”
St. John was eventually swept up in Woodrow Wilson's mass federal indictment of Wobblies in 1918 and sent to Leavenworth. Passed over for the customary Christmas pardon by the vengeful Wilson in 1920, he had to wait for his sentence to be commuted by Warren Harding in 1923.
Such treatment was routine for socialists of that era, when it was popular enough to pose a real threat to the system. St. John's fellow Wobbly Lucy Parsons, for example, wife of the Haymarket martyr Albert Parsons, was subjected to constant surveillance, had meeting halls abruptly closed to her at the last minute, and was thrown in jail when she refused to respect a ban on her speaking in public imposed by the mayor of Columbus, Ohio. She was arrested again along with her two children even as her husband was being executed, with one of the officers commenting that she was "more to be feared than a thousand rioters."
A militant socialist and radical journalist active for over sixty years, Parsons did not go in for what would be called identity politics today. She argued that racism and sexism were overshadowed by exploitation of the working class as a whole, and therefore should not be considered independent oppressions. Women were exploited in a special way because that depressed the wages of all workers. Blacks were subject to lynch law because they were the poorest and most defenseless part of the working class. The point, Parsons said, was that sex and race were facts of life manipulated by employers seeking to justify super-exploitation of groups already targeted as inferior by class. All groups of workers, she felt, whatever their mix of gender and race, should devote their complete energy to engaging class struggle.
Parsons really meant it when advocating for all workers. In an era when prostitutes were routinely ignored she stood up for them, telling her fellow Wobblies that she spoke for "my sisters whom I can see in the night when I go out in Chicago."
Parsons eventually became a Communist and an active worker for the International Labor Defense. She also fought for the release of labor leader Tom Mooney, falsely accused of a Preparedness Day bombing in San Francisco, as well as the Scottsboro Nine in Alabama and for the young black Communist Angelo Herndon. Her fearless defiance over a lifetime has rarely been equaled and perhaps never surpassed.
But one woman who came pretty close was Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, who became a spellbinding street speaker by her mid-teens. When the IWW struck dramatically in the East for the first time (1912), she helped lead one of its most amazing strikes ever in Lawrence Massachusetts.
Twenty thousand textile workers without a dime to their names walked off the job in mid-winter to protest a cut in their already desperately low pay. Accusing their employers of wrecking families, they protested their having “taken away our wives from the homes, our children ... from the playground, stolen out of schools and driven into the mills, where they were strapped to the machines, not only to force the fathers to compete, but that their young lives may be coined into dollars for a parasite class, that their very nerves, their laughter and joy denied, may be woven into cloth.” Reverend Harry Emerson Fosdick, a stockholder in the American Woolen Company, responded for the employers, explaining with admirable directness that, “Any man who pays more for labor than the lowest sum he can get men for is robbing his stockholders.”
Although the
employers had all the usual advantages of wealth and power, the I.W.W.’s direct action won the day. Flynn, the “Joan of Arc of Labor,” mesmerized the workers with her poignant explanations of class warfare, goading them to collective action.
“Would you like to have nice clothes?” she rhetorically asked throngs of poor immigrant women. “Oh, yes!” they shouted in enthusiastic unison. “Well, you can’t have them,” she snapped. “Your bosses’ daughters have those things!”
Deftly prodding the women to ponder a series of unanticipated injustices they had been forced to endure, she proceeded to ask them why they had abandoned their native villages in the "old world,"
their aged parents, and their children to come to an alien U.S.,
knowing full well they had come for a better life, free
from tyranny and oppression, landlords and military conscription, an abundant
life of steady work, savings, education for their children, and a chance to
send for others.
“What freedom?” Flynn shouted at them, blasting their fervent wishes with a harsh dose of class reality. She asked if they were free
when they were herded into fortress-like New England mills, or when they
were branded as inferiors and intruders, or when they were disdained as
“Greenhorns” and “Hunkies.” She asked if they were free as wage slaves,
hired and fired at the whim of a soulless company, paid unlivable wages
for grueling hours tending a whizzing machine. She asked if they were
free when they were clubbed, jailed, and shot down in the street, or
when politicians ignored their suffering because they couldn’t vote.
Bringing them to the very edge of despair, she then showed them a way out, the only way out, urging them to neutralize the police and militia by putting down their tools, folding their arms, and bringing machinery, production, and profits to a halt. She poignantly inquired: “Can they weave cloth with soldiers’ bayonets or policemen’s clubs?” “Did they dig coal with bayonets in the miners’ strikes or make steel or run trains with bayonets?”
Heads nodded and eyes welled up with tears as Flynn unveiled
a magical new English word: “Solidarity.”
Labor journalist Mary
Heaton Vorse, a friend of Flynn’s, never forgot what she witnessed on the streets of Lawrence: “She
stirred them, lifted them up in her appeal for solidarity ... It was as
though a spurt of flame had gone through the audience ... . Something
beautiful and strong had swept through the people and welded them
together, singing.”
In the face of this determined worker resistance, the mill owners’ bag of repressive
tricks for once failed them. They banned fixed picket lines by local ordinance,
but the strikers responded with a roving human chain that circulated the
mills 24 hours a day, while supporting crowds surged through town
singing labor songs and occupying department stores. They imported
scabs, but the strikers denied them sleep, serenading them with mocking
choirs that recorded their names and sent them back to their native
lands to disgrace their families. Police, clerics, mill management, and
city officials tried to proceed with business as usual, but found they could not, as they were loudly jeered at wherever they went. Soldiers discovered the
backs of their uniforms being suddenly shredded by scissors
emerging from beneath long cloaks. Female gangs stripped the proud
forces of order bare, forcing them to flee in humiliation while the
women hooted and pointed at their nakedness.
National publicity
of a tactical blunder proved decisive. Besieged by police, militia, and
cavalry, the workers arranged for host families in neighboring towns to
temporarily care for their children. In mid-winter Margaret Sanger helped escort a
flock of “pale, emaciated, dejected children” to the train station, all
of them lacking even “a stitch of wool on their bodies.” Troopers
surrounded the station and the police attacked, clubbing the children
and tearing them away from their parents. Dozens of frantic women and
kids were beaten, arrested, and thrown kicking and screaming into patrol
wagons.
Hauled away to jail, the parents were charged with “neglect” and improper guardianship while their children were shipped off to the Lawrence Poor Farm. Livid strikers besieged the police station while shock reverberated throughout the country at the cowardly attack on children. The U.S. Bureau of Labor ordered an investigation and the House Committee on Rules opened hearings on the strike and the textile industry. Governor Foss of Massachusetts suddenly informed the mill owners that the state troopers had to be withdrawn.
The mill agents’ smug confidence that workers divided into countless different crafts and nationalities couldn’t possibly pull off a strike proved to be unfounded. With public support cratering and the loss of their tariff on imported woolens increasingly likely, the companies gave in, granting the strikers a raise, reduced hours, overtime pay, and a promise not to retaliate for the strike.
Throngs of exuberant workers poured into the streets celebrating their stunning victory, joyously singing the Internationale in two dozen languages.
That's what socialism looks like. Don't let anyone tell you differently.
*At the time there were five million white workers in the South, only marginally less impoverished than the four million freed slaves. The perpetuation of racist rule post-slavery made sure the working class remained weak and divided.
Sources:
The New York Tribune quote is from John Nichols, The 'S' Word - A Short History Of An American Tradition . . . Socialism, (Verso, 2015), p. 65
On labor government during Reconstruction:
W. E. B. DuBois, "Black Reconstruction In America," (New York: Russell & Russell, 1935)
On the IWW:
Bird, Stewart with Dan Georgakas and Deborah Shaffer, Solidarity Forever - An Oral History of the I.W.W. (Lake View Press, 1985)
-----Dubofsky, Melvyn, We Shall Be All - A History of the Industrial Workers of the World (University of Illinois, 1988)
Renshaw, Patrick, The Wobblies - The Story of the I.W.W. and Syndicalism in the United States, (Ivan R. Dee, 1999)
Foner, Philip S., ed., History of the Labor Movement in The United States, Volume 4, The Industrial Workers of the World, 1905-1917, (International Publishers, 1965)
Milkman, Ruth, ed., Women, Work & Protest - A Century of U.S. Women’s Labor History (Routledge & Keegan Paul, 1985)
Zinn, Howard, The Zinn Reader, (Seven Stories, 1997)
On Elizabeth Gurley Flynn:
Camp, Helen C., Iron In Her Soul - Elizabeth Gurley Flynn and the American Left, (Washington State University Press, 1995)
Flynn, Elizabeth Gurley, The Rebel Girl, (International Publishers, 1955)
Garrison, Dee, Mary Heaton Vorse - The Life of an American Insurgent, (Temple University, 1989)
Watson, Bruce, Bread and Roses - Mills, Migrants, And The Struggle For The American Dream, (Viking, 2005)
On Big Bill Haywood:
Dubofsky, Melvyn, ‘Big Bill’ Haywood, (Manchester University Press, 1987)
On Vincent St. John:
Lens, Sidney, The Labor Wars - From the Molly Maguires to the Sitdowns, (Anchor, 1973)
On Lucy Parsons:
Davis, Angela Y., Women, Race & Class, (Vintage, 1983)