Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Three Cheers For The Revival of Socialism

"Our idea is that Labor needs not to combat but to command Capital."

-----New York Tribune, 1860

 A wave of democratic socialists speaking the menacing language of sharing, caring, and reciprocity has reared its ugly head and ridden an anti-Trump wave to the halls of Congress. An embattled GOP must now figure out how to beat back its worst nightmare: an array of policies designed to stop wholesale slaughter in the Middle East and bring affordable medical care, child care, housing, and university education to all as a matter of right.

The Republicans' terrifying challenge is only partially a response to Donald Trump. At a deeper level it is part of an effort to put labor in power that extends back to Reconstruction (1865-1877), where it was partially achieved, albeit only temporarily, and only in the South. That effort was crushed by an alliance of Northern capital and Southern planters that unleashed waves of paramilitary terror against recently freed slaves to implement a system of slavery without chattel that lasted into the civil rights era.*

Meanwhile, in the North, robber baron savagery sowed the seeds of a socialist rebellion that emerged in force in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when a dizzying spate of corporate mergers catapulted a few hundred firms into control of more than forty percent of the industrial capital of the country. "Free" labor then enjoyed the unparalleled liberty to prostitute itself to rising monopoly power or die on the streets begging for charity. Government help was unheard of at the time.

By 1905, labor's finest leaders had had enough of the capitalist cycle of boom, bust, panic, and collapse that left workers in perpetual misery. In June, Big Bill Haywood lumbered onto the platform at Brand's Hall in Chicago, gaveled the podium with a piece of loose board, and called the assembly to order. Flanked by socialist Eugene Debs, labor firebrand Mother Jones, and African-American anarchist Lucy Parsons, he announced the birth of the Industrial Workers of the World, a union of native-born radicals whose capacity for militant solidarity was and remains unmatched in U.S. history.

Haywood told the two hundred plus delegates crammed into the hot, overcrowded hall that they were "the Continental Congress of the working class," adding that "the aims and objects of this organization should be to put the working class in possession of the economic power, the means of life, in control of production and distribution, without regard to capitalist masters." This ambition was to be fulfilled, not by violent seizure of state power, but by paralyzing big business with a series of general strikes, culminating in direct workers' control of all industries.

Haywood was one of the most popular labor leaders in the country at the time. A child of the West, he was recognized on the streets of New York the way a star athlete might be today. Adored by women and instinctively obeyed by men, he possessed of the manners of a gentleman, packed a revolver, and cried like a baby when reciting poetry. His thunderous orations ignited crowds of workers like a wick in a powder keg. “Eight hours of work, eight hours of play, eight hours of sleep, EIGHT DOLLARS A DAY!”

The brutality of wage work had taught Haywood of injustice early and converted him to socialism. His first boss whipped him when he was only twelve, and the same year he witnessed a black man surrendered to the tender mercies of a lynch mob. Three years later he was a Nevada miner doing a “man’s work for a boy’s pay,” breaking the loneliness of Eagle Canyon reading Darwin, Marx, Burns, Voltaire, Byron, and Shakespeare. An older miner’s explanation of the class struggle capped his education, though the lesson didn’t sink in until the Haymarket anarchists were hung two years later (1887).

In subsequent years Haywood saw scores of men poisoned at Utah’s Brooklyn lead mine, watched a friend’s head crushed against an air drill by a slab of falling rock, and had his own right hand smashed between a descending car and the side of the shaft at Iowa’s Silver City mine. “I’ve never read Marx’s Capital,” he liked to say, “but I have the marks of capital all over me.” Of the class warfare that made such disfigurement routine, he said: “[The] barbarous gold barons do not find the gold, they do not mine the gold, they do not mill the gold, but by some weird alchemy all the gold belongs to them.”

Another great socialist and IWW leader, though virtually unknown today, was Vincent Saint John. Son of a pony express rider, he was, variously, a delivery boy, a farm hand, a tinner, a printer, an upholsterer, a prospecter, a miner, and a militant unionist. 

In the 1890s he had ruined his lungs rescuing dozens of men from a smoke-filled mine in Telluride. In 1901, his men rewarded him with the presidency of the Telluride miners’ union at the tender age of 25. St. John promptly armed them with 250 rifles and 50,000 rounds of ammunition, which they used to ambush scabs from behind boulders and trees and shoot their way into possession of the mines.

“The air smelled clean in his presence,” said one of St. John's men, who nicknamed him “the Saint” to honor his incorruptibility. The mine owners, on the other hand, called him a dynamiter, a gunman, and a dangerous agitator—and always kept a price on his head.  With a graduate degree from the school of hard knocks St. John’s only creed was action.

In 1906, he found himself at the center of a brutal labor struggle in Goldfield, Nevada, the biggest, busiest, richest gold camp in the world. Crowded with dance halls, saloons, and gambling houses, it was a boom town swarming with claim jumpers, fortune hunters, and gamblers, all drawn to the gold like children to candy from every district in the West. 

St. John recruited 20,000 local workers for the I.W.W., including miners, dishwashers, engineers, stenographers, teamsters, clerks, newsboys, croupiers, maids, and prostitutes. He established the eight-hour day, guaranteed a minimum daily wage of $4.50 for all, and abolished individual begging for jobs. Any employer wishing to hire workers had to come and negotiate with the union committees. A company detective explained to the Rocky Mountain News that the I.W.W. leader posed an intolerable threat to high society wherever he went: “St. John has given the mine owners of Colorado more trouble in the past years than twenty other men up there. If left undisturbed, he would have the entire district organized in another year.” 

St. John contemporary and fellow Wobbly Elizabeth Gurley Flynn was yet another outstanding socialist. When the IWW struck dramatically in the East for the first time (1912) She helped lead one of its most memorable strikes in Lawrence Massachusetts. 

Twenty thousand textile workers without a dime to their names walked off the job in mid-winter to protest a cut in their already desperately low pay. Accusing their employers of wrecking families, they charged them with having “taken away our wives from the homes, our children ... from the playground, stolen out of schools and driven into the mills, where they were strapped to the machines, not only to force the fathers to compete, but that their young lives may be coined into dollars for a parasite class, that their very nerves, their laughter and joy denied, may be woven into cloth ... .” Reverend Harry Emerson Fosdick, a stockholder in the American Woolen Company, responded for the employers, explaining with admirable directness that, “Any man who pays more for labor than the lowest sum he can get men for is robbing his stockholders.”

The employers had all the usual advantages of wealth and power, but the I.W.W.’s direct action won the day. Flynn, the “Joan of Arc of Labor,” mesmerized workers with her poignant explanations of class warfare, goading them to collective action.

“Would you like to have nice clothes?” she rhetorically asked throngs of poor immigrant women. “Oh, yes!” they shouted in enthusiastic unison. “Well, you can’t have them,” she snapped. “Your bosses’ daughters have those things!” 

Leading the women through a series of unanticipated injustices they had been forced to endure, sheproceeded to ask them why they had abandoned their native villages in the "old world," their aged parents, and their children to come to an alien U.S., knowing full well they had come for a better life, free from tyranny and oppression, landlords and military conscription, an abundant life of steady work, savings, education for their children, and a chance to send for others.

“What freedom?” Flynn shouted at them, blasting their fervent wishes with a harsh dose of class reality. She asked if they were free when they were herded into fortress-like New England mills, or when they were branded as inferiors and intruders, or when they were disdained as “Greenhorns” and “Hunkies.” She asked if they were free as wage slaves, hired and fired at the whim of a soulless company, paid unlivable wages for grueling hours tending a whizzing machine. She asked if they were free when they were clubbed, jailed, and shot down in the street, or when politicians ignored their suffering because they couldn’t vote.

Bringing them to the edge of despair, she then showed them a way out, the only way out. She urged the women to neutralize the police and militia by putting down their tools, folding their arms, and bringing machinery, production, and profits to a halt. She poignantly inquired: “Can they weave cloth with soldiers’ bayonets or policemen’s clubs?” “Did they dig coal with bayonets in the miners’ strikes or make steel or run trains with bayonets?” 

Heads nodded and eyes welled up with tears as Flynn unveiled a magical new English word: “Solidarity.”

Labor journalist Mary Heaton Vorse, a friend of Flynn’s, never forgot what she witnessed in the Lawrence textile strike: “She stirred them, lifted them up in her appeal for solidarity ... It was as though a spurt of flame had gone through the audience ... . Something beautiful and strong had swept through the people and welded them together, singing.”


In the face of this determined worker resistance, the mill owners’ bag of repressive tricks for once failed them. They banned fixed picket lines by local ordinance, but the strikers responded with a roving human chain that circulated the mills 24 hours a day, while supporting crowds surged through town singing labor songs and occupying department stores. They imported scabs, but the strikers denied them sleep, serenading them with mocking choirs that recorded their names and sent them back to their native lands to disgrace their families. Police, clerics, mill management, and city officials tried to proceed with business as usual, but found they could not, as they were loudly jeered at wherever they went. Soldiers discovered the backs of their uniforms being suddenly shredded by scissors emerging from beneath long cloaks. Female gangs stripped the proud forces of order bare, forcing them to flee in humiliation while the women hooted and pointed at their nakedness.

National publicity of a tactical blunder proved decisive. Besieged by police, militia, and cavalry, the workers arranged for host families in neighboring towns to temporarily care for their children. In mid-winter Margaret Sanger helped escort a flock of “pale, emaciated, dejected children” to the train station, all of them lacking even “a stitch of wool on their bodies.” Troopers surrounded the station and the police attacked, clubbing the children and tearing them away from their parents. Dozens of frantic women and kids were beaten, arrested, and thrown kicking and screaming into patrol wagons. 

Hauled away to jail, the parents were charged with “neglect” and improper guardianship, while their children were shipped off to the Lawrence Poor Farm. Livid strikers besieged the police station while shock reverberated throughout the country at the cowardly attack on children. The U.S. Bureau of Labor ordered an investigation and the House Committee on Rules opened hearings on the strike and the textile industry. Governor Foss of Massachusetts suddenly informed the mill owners that the state troopers had to be withdrawn.

The mill agents’ smug confidence that workers divided into countless different crafts and nationalities couldn’t possibly pull off a strike proved to be unfounded. With public support cratering and the loss of their tariff on imported woolens increasingly likely, the companies gave in, granting the strikers a raise, reduced hours, overtime pay, and a promise not to retaliate for the strike.

Crowds of exuberant workers celebrated their stunning victory, joyously singing the Internationale in two dozen languages.

If socialism is back, one should only say: Welcome, we've been expecting you.

 

*At the time there were five million white workers in the South, only marginally less impoverished than the four million freed slaves. The perpetuation of racist rule post-slavery made sure the working class remained weak and divided.

 

Sources: 

New York Tribune quote is from John Nichols, "The 'S' Word - A Short History Of An American Tradition . . . Socialism," (Verso, 2015), p. 65

On labor government during Reconstruction:

W. E. B. DuBois, "Black Reconstruction In America," (New York: Russell & Russell, 1935) 

On the IWW:

Bird, Stewart with Dan Georgakas and Deborah Shaffer, Solidarity Forever - An Oral History of the I.W.W. (Lake View Press, 1985)

-----Dubofsky, Melvyn, We Shall Be All - A History of the Industrial Workers of the World (University of Illinois, 1988)

Renshaw, Patrick, The Wobblies - The Story of the I.W.W. and Syndicalism in the United States, (Ivan R. Dee, 1999)

Foner, Philip S., ed., History of the Labor Movement in The United States, Volume 4, The Industrial Workers of the World, 1905-1917, (International Publishers, 1965) 

Milkman, Ruth, ed., Women, Work & Protest - A Century of U.S. Women’s Labor History (Routledge & Keegan Paul, 1985)

Zinn, Howard, The Zinn Reader, (Seven Stories, 1997) 

On Elizabeth Gurley Flynn: 

Camp, Helen C., Iron In Her Soul - Elizabeth Gurley Flynn and the American Left, (Washington State University Press, 1995)

Flynn, Elizabeth Gurley, The Rebel Girl, (International Publishers, 1955)

Garrison, Dee, Mary Heaton Vorse - The Life of an American Insurgent, (Temple University, 1989)

On Big Bill Haywood: 

Dubofsky, Melvyn, ‘Big Bill’ Haywood, (Manchester University Press, 1987)

On Vincent St. John:

Lens, Sidney, The Labor Wars - From the Molly Maguires to the Sitdowns, (Anchor, 1973)





 

 


When Working Class Heroes Were Something To Be: Celebrating the IWW on Labor Day

By Michael K. Smith

One hundred and four years ago Big Bill Haywood lumbered onto the platform at Brand’s Hall in Chicago, gaveled the podium with a piece of loose board, and called the assembly to order. Flanked by Eugene Debs, Mother Jones, and Lucy Parsons, he announced the birth of the Industrial Workers of the World, a union of native-born radicals whose capacity for militant solidarity was and remains unmatched in U.S. history.

Haywood told the two hundred plus delegates crammed into the hot, overcrowded hall that they were “the Continental Congress of the working class,” adding that, “The aims and objects of this organization should be to put the working class in possession of the economic power, the means of life, in control of production and distribution, without regard to capitalist masters.” This ambition was to be fulfilled, not by violent seizure of state power, but by paralyzing big business with a series of general strikes, culminating in direct workers’ control of all industries.

After trekking to the graves of the 1886 Haymarket martyrs buried in Waldheim Cemetery, the I.W.W. delegates passed a resolution endorsing the Russian revolution then in progress. The preamble of their constitution announced a complete divorce from those who rented their labor: “The working class and the employing class have nothing in common. There can be no peace so long as hunger and want are found among millions of working people and the few who make up the capitalist class have all the good things in life.” Therefore, conflict “must go on until all the toilers come together ... and take and hold that which they produce by their labor.”

Revolutionary in spirit, the “Wobblies” plunged directly into danger, demanding their due without haggling or hassle. They saw the profit system as one giant leach on the back of the working class, and insisted that compromise between owners and workers made no more sense than between a fungus and blighted potato. Determined to gain control of production, not negotiate the terms of subservience, they disdained gradualism as procrastination and disliked contracts for surrendering the right to strike at any time. They had even less regard for elections, agreeing with the socialist priest Father Hagerty that, “Dropping pieces of paper into a hole in a box never did achieve emancipation.”

Furthermore, where other unions shunned the lowly in preference for the “skilled,” the I.W.W. welcomed all races, privileged no one, included housework as a category of labor, and organized chambermaids and prostitutes. The answer to the owners’ One Big Trust, they declared, was One Big Union, which, they believed, was the prelude to a society where all would take their share of production and receive the necessities of life without resort to money.

Outdoor workers addicted to jokes and wild stories, the Wobblies thrived on disaster—and had to—as they were constantly attacked by police, shot by militia, beaten by scabs and vigilantes, and bitterly denounced as “the scum of the earth” by a business press dedicated to egging the bullies on. For Wobblies to speak their minds was itself a crime, and they were regularly dragged off soapboxes for reading seditious material—like the U.S. Constitution. Characterized by soaring idealism and police brutality, these “free speech fights,” as they came to be known, featured Wobblies dropping their tools for hundreds of miles around and walking or riding the rails to besiege the conflict zone. There they sang, shouted, lectured, and put on skits until the jails were swamped, a city’s treasury was drained, and the First Amendment was recognized. The San Diego Tribune supplied a standard press reaction in 1912: “Hanging is none too good for them and they would be much better dead; for they are absolutely useless in the human economy; they are waste material of creation and should be drained off in the sewer of oblivion there to rot in cold obstruction like any other excrement.”

The most famous—and infamous—of Wobblies was the nationally renowned “Big Bill” Haywood. A child of the West, he was recognized on the streets of New York the way a star athlete might be today. Adored by women and instinctively obeyed by men, he was the most popular unionist in the country. Possessed of the manners of a gentleman, he packed a revolver, cried like a baby when reciting poetry, and delivered thunderous orations that ignited crowds of workers like a wick in a powder keg.

The brutality of wage work taught Haywood of injustice early and converted him to socialism. His first boss whipped him when he was only twelve, and the same year he witnessed a black man surrendered to the tender mercies of a lynch mob. Three years later he was a Nevada miner doing a “man’s work for a boy’s pay,” breaking the loneliness of Eagle Canyon reading Darwin, Marx, Burns, Voltaire, Byron, and Shakespeare. An older miner’s explanation of the class struggle capped his education, though the lesson didn’t sink in until the Haymarket anarchists were hung two years later.

In subsequent years Haywood saw scores of men poisoned at Utah’s Brooklyn lead mine, watched a friend’s head crushed against an air drill by a slab of falling rock, and had his own right hand smashed between a descending car and the side of the shaft at Iowa’s Silver City mine. “I’ve never read Marx’s Capital,” he liked to say, “but I have the marks of capital all over me.” Of the class subordination that made such disfigurement routine, he said this: “[The] barbarous gold barons do not find the gold, they do not mine the gold, they do not mill the gold, but by some weird alchemy all the gold belongs to them.”

After Haywood in the annals of great I.W.W. leaders came Vincent Saint John. Son of a pony express rider, he was also a delivery boy, a farm hand, a tinner, a printer, an upholsterer, a prospecter, a miner, and a militant unionist. In the 1890s he had ruined his lungs rescuing dozens of men from a smoke-filled mine in Telluride. In 1901, his men rewarded him with the presidency of the Telluride miners’ union at the tender age of 25. St. John promptly armed them with 250 rifles and 50,000 rounds of ammunition, which they used to ambush scabs from behind boulders and trees and shoot their way into possession of the mines.

His men nicknamed him “the Saint” to honor his incorruptibility, with one of them remembering later that “the air smelled clean in his presence.” On the other hand, the mine owners considered him a dynamiter, a gunman, and a dangerous agitator—and always kept a price on his head. With a graduate degree from the school of hard knocks St. John’s only creed was action.

In 1906, he found himself at the center of a brutal labor struggle in Goldfield, Nevada, the biggest, busiest, richest gold camp in the world. Crowded with dance halls, saloons, and gambling houses, it was a boom town swarming with claim jumpers, fortune hunters, and gamblers, all drawn to the gold like children to candy from every district in the West. St. John recruited 20,000 local workers for the I.W.W., including miners, dishwashers, engineers, stenographers, teamsters, clerks, newsboys, croupiers, maids, and prostitutes. He established the eight-hour day, guaranteed a minimum daily wage of $4.50 for all, and abolished begging for jobs. Any employer wishing to hire workers had to come and negotiate with the union committees. A company detective explained to the Rocky Mountain News that the I.W.W. leader posed an intolerable threat to civilized society wherever he went: “St. John has given the mine owners of Colorado more trouble in the past years than twenty other men up there. If left undisturbed, he would have the entire district organized in another year.”

But the Wobblies were really about the rank-and-file. Striking dramatically in the East for the first time, the I.W.W. led one of its most memorable strikes in Lawrence Massachusetts in 1912, where 20,000 textile workers without a dime to their names walked off the job in mid-winter to protest a cut in their already desperately low pay. Accusing their employers of wrecking families, they charged them with having “taken away our wives from the homes, our children ... from the playground, stolen out of schools and driven into the mills, where they were strapped to the machines, not only to force the fathers to compete, but that their young lives may be coined into dollars for a parasite class, that their very nerves, their laughter and joy denied, may be woven into cloth ... .” Reverend Harry Emerson Fosdick, a stockholder in the American Woolen Company, responded for the employers, explaining with admirable directness that, “Any man who pays more for labor than the lowest sum he can get men for is robbing his stockholders.”

The employers held all the cards, but the I.W.W.’s direct action proved to be trump. Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, the “Joan of Arc of Labor,” mesmerized the workers with her poignant explanations of class warfare. “Would you like to have nice clothes?” she rhetorically asked throngs of immigrant women. “Oh, yes!” they shouted in unison. “Well, you can’t have them,” she responded. “Your bosses’ daughters have those things!” Flynn then proceeded to ask the women why they had abandoned their native villages, their aged parents, and their children to come to an alien land, knowing full well they had come for a better life in the New World, free from tyranny and oppression, from landlords and military conscription, a life of work, savings, education for their children, and a chance to send for others.

“What freedom?” Flynn shouted, blasting their hopes with a harsh dose of class reality. She asked if they were free when they were herded into fortress-like New England mills, or when they were branded as inferiors and intruders, or when they were disdained as “Greenhorns” and “Hunkies.” She asked if they were free as wage slaves, hired and fired at the whim of a soulless company, paid unlivable wages for grueling hours tending a whizzing machine. She asked if they were free when they were clubbed, jailed, and shot down in the street, or when politicians ignored their suffering because they couldn’t vote.

Urging the women to neutralize the police and militia by putting down their tools, folding their arms, and bringing machinery, production, and profits to a halt, she poignantly inquired: “Can they weave cloth with soldiers’ bayonets or policemen’s clubs?” “Did they dig coal with bayonets in the miners’ strikes or make steel or run trains with bayonets?” Heads nodded and eyes welled up with tears as Flynn explained a magical new English word: “Solidarity.”

Labor journalist Mary Heaton Vorse, a friend of Flynn’s, never forgot what she witnessed: “She stirred them, lifted them up in her appeal for solidarity ... It was as though a spurt of flame had gone through the audience ... . Something beautiful and strong had swept through the people and welded them together, singing.”

For once, the mill owners’ bag of repressive tricks failed them. They banned fixed picket lines by local ordinance, but the strikers responded with a roving human chain that circulated the mills 24 hours a day, while supporting crowds surged through town singing labor songs and occupying department stores. They imported scabs, but the strikers denied them sleep, serenading them with mocking choirs that recorded their names and sent them back to their native lands to disgrace their families. Police, clerics, mill management, and city officials tried to proceed with business as usual, but found themselves loudly jeered at wherever they went. Soldiers discovered the backs of their uniforms being suddenly shredded by anonymous scissors emerging from beneath long cloaks. Female gangs stripped the proud forces of order bare, forcing them to flee in humiliation while the women hooted and pointed at their nakedness.

National publicity of a tactical blunder proved decisive. Besieged by police, militia, and cavalry, the workers arranged for host families in neighboring towns to temporarily care for their children. Margaret Sanger helped escort a flock of “pale, emaciated, dejected children” to the train station, all of them lacking even “a stitch of wool on their bodies.” Troopers surrounded the station and the police attacked, clubbing the children and tearing them away from their parents. Dozens of frantic women and kids were beaten, arrested, and thrown kicking and screaming into patrol wagons. Hauled away to jail, the parents were charged with “neglect” and improper guardianship, while their children were shipped off to the Lawrence Poor Farm. Livid strikers besieged the police station as shock reverberated throughout the country at the cowardly attack on children. The U.S. Bureau of Labor ordered an investigation and the House Committee on Rules opened hearings on the strike and the textile industry. Governor Foss of Massachusetts suddenly informed the mill owners that the state troopers had to be withdrawn.

The mill agents’ smug confidence that workers divided into countless different crafts and nationalities couldn’t possibly pull off a strike proved to be unfounded. With public support cratering and the loss of their tariff on imported woolens increasingly likely, the companies gave in, granting the strikers a raise, reduced hours, overtime pay, and a promise not to retaliate for the strike.

Crowds of exuberant workers celebrated their stunning victory, joyously singing the Internationale in two dozen languages.

Sources:

Bird, Stewart with Dan Georgakas and Deborah Shaffer, Solidarity Forever - An Oral History of the I.W.W. (Lake View Press, 1985)

Camp, Helen C., Iron In Her Soul - Elizabeth Gurley Flynn and the American Left, (Washington State University Press, 1995)

Dubofsky, Melvyn, ‘Big Bill’ Haywood, (Manchester University Press, 1987)

-----We Shall Be All - A History of the Industrial Workers of the World (University of Illinois, 1988)

Flynn, Elizabeth Gurley, The Rebel Girl, (International Publishers, 1955)

Foner, Philip S., ed., History of the Labor Movement in The United States, Volume 4, The Industrial Workers of the World, 1905-1917, (International Publishers, 1965)

Garrison, Dee, Mary Heaton Vorse - The Life of an American Insurgent, (Temple University, 1989)

Lens, Sidney, The Labor Wars - From the Molly Maguires to the Sitdowns, (Anchor, 1973)

Milkman, Ruth, ed., Women, Work & Protest - A Century of U.S. Women’s Labor History (Routledge & Keegan Paul, 1985)

Renshaw, Patrick, The Wobblies - The Story of the I.W.W. and Syndicalism in the United States, (Ivan R. Dee, 1999)

Zinn, Howard, The Zinn Reader, (Seven Stories, 1997)

Michael K. Smith is the author of “Portraits of Empire,” “The Madness of King George (with Matt Wuerker), and “Rise To Empire” (forthcoming), all from Common Courage Press.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

A Resounding Defeat For Trump

Backpedaling like a whirling dervish, TACO* Trump claims that yesterday's crushing electoral defeat has nothing to do with him as he wasn't even on the ballot, which ignores the fact that throughout the mid-term campaign he harangued his followers to vote as though he were on the ballot. 

Voters appear to have taken him at his word, handing control of the entire Congress to a far from popular Democratic Party, as well as the state governorships that were in play. The most eye-catching result may be that Democratic candidates won not only in so-called purple states, a customary kind of shift in mid-term elections, but also in states that until yesterday were considered permanent Republican strongholds, like South Carolina and Kansas. The last time Kansas had a Democratic Senator was 1939.

Just as significant as the magnitude of yesterday's rejection is the responsibility for it, which falls squarely on Trump. He strove to make the elections about his persona, even when polls indicated his average popularity had dipped under 37%, an all-time low.  At the beginning of the year nobody was saying that the deeply-disliked Democrats had any prospects for taking control of both houses of Congress. As late as May, 59% of U.S. adults had an unfavorable opinion of the party.

Four prominent factors largely account for yesterday's results. One, Trump's intervention in the GOP's internal processes of candidate selection, in many cases choosing inexperienced and corrupt acolytes with divisive profiles over more vetted party favorites. Two, and also three, as the factors overlap, was the unprovoked attack on Iran, which Trump himself said would be a particularly stupid target for a regime-change war, a policy he claimed to have rejected no matter where it might be proposed, on the basis of the disastrous outcome of the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq. In short, his Iran attack went directly against his own advice against "forever wars," while also unleashing a ferocious wave of inflation on American workers, a large majority of whom live precariously from paycheck-to-paycheck to begin with. This third factor erased the 2024 voter perception that Trump would be the better bet to manage the economy well.  Add to this Trump's comments that he gave no thought to the impact on American wallets of plunging the Middle East into prolonged war, and his retrospective justification that no one should resent soaring gas prices because the oil companies were making "a freaking fortune," and one should have no difficulty seeing that Trump was practically begging for a voter backlash.

Finally, Trump's vicious and indiscriminate witch-hunt against immigrants, regardless of their legal status, expelled the Latino vote from the Trump coalition, a crucial part of his previous victories as well as any continuing hopes for Republican governing majorities. The best illustration of this change in voting preferences was seen in Texas, where James Talarico (Senate) and Gina Hinojosa (Governor) crushed their conservative opponents by margins nobody foresaw. In Florida, the far-right came very close to losing its stronghold in the face of liberal challengers. 

Having said all this, it remains clear that yesterday's vote does not represent a blank check for the Democratic Party, but rather a thunderous rejection of Trump himself, his arrogance, his perverse priorities, and his extreme policies. Very noteworthy in this rejection was the highly competitive performance of democratic socialist candidates, most of them young and from ethnic minorities typically marginalized or stigmatized. They fearlessly confronted the open contempt the Republican party holds for them, as well as the craven submission of corporate Democrats to cowardly and hypocritical compromises. They and millions of their fellow-Americans didn't allow themselves to be manipulated by the lies and distortions of Republican candidates awash in billionaire cash.

Having said that, however, California's Proposition 40, a modest tax on billionaires, appears to be going down to defeat on the pretext that billionaires might move out of state in response, as though their assets wouldn't be taxed nonetheless.

As the final electoral results continue streaming in, the great question now hovering over the United States and the world is how the Republican Party will react to restrictions on its power, until now allowed to lurch from one disaster to the next without restraint.  

In typical Trumpian style, the early signals have been contradictory: to the New York Times Trump said he was disposed to accept the results, and that he would probably make an agreement with the Democrats. On the other hand, before the polls closed he had assured CBS News the presidential veto gave him "the ultimate power," while the Supreme Court had granted him "tremendous powers" over federal agencies without regard to who controls Congress. 

With Democratic Party leadership in the hands of the likes of Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer it would be foolish to expect an abrupt shift into rational policy. On the other hand, they will be under strong pressure to appease a rising social democratic party base intoxicated with the exotic notion that democracy means representative power.

One can only hope that this means Democratic Party cowardice has a limit, which would be very good news, as Trump's appetite for despotic authority clearly doesn't.  


*Trump Always Chickens Out



Monday, October 26, 2026

Trump Loathes Everyone, Especially His Loyal Supporters

". . . assume that Trump has complete and total contempt for everyone in the country . . . . If you didn't vote at all he's probably (at best) indifferent to you. If you voted against him he hates you and wants you to suffer pain, and he wants revenge against you. If you voted for him, he thinks you're a mark and he has contempt for you."

 -----Ryan Grim, Breaking Points, October 26, 2026 

 

"I could say the stupidest things and you'd still clap". . . (laughter and applause) . . .

------ Donald Trump, campaign rally, Clarkson Tennessee, October 10, 2026

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Questions About "Jane Doe" and The Cornell 7

Why would anyone have 10 drinks and go to a frat house? 

Why would a supposed "friend" hand her a beer as soon as she arrived, obviously drunk already? 

With his friend's mind and body already impaired by alcohol, why would he even think of sex? 

Why would they both snort ketamine, a drug that produces bodily numbness? Marijuana, at least, is a sex-enhancing drug (in small quantities) but on top of large doses of alcohol and ketamine obviously would not be. What on earth were they thinking? 

Aren't people who need to disinhibit themselves this much completely unready for sex?

Why would anyone have sex in a dorm room not their own? (The room was NOT a dorm room, but a private room in a frat house. It was Mathew Ingalls's living space, who is the one who invited "Jane Doe" to have sex - Ed.)

Why would anyone make a snapchat and send out a general invitation to come and get "free pussy"? Why would anyone accept such an invitation?

Why is there only one recognized quantity in recreational drug culture - more? No matter how intoxicated one is, it's always one stage short of the recommended state until one is literally comatose. 

Why is college life dominated by such a degenerate culture?

Monday, October 5, 2026

The Cornell 7 and the House Negro 3

"Why is it that if a woman has sex with a man and she's very drunk and high, he becomes a rapist on the grounds that she drank too much and took too many drugs to consent, but if he's just as high or drunk, or more so, why isn't she guilty of rape, since he can't consent either?"

                                                                 -----Glenn Greenwald

Here we go again. 

The accuser of the "Cornell 7" voluntarily had ten drinks in three hours before going to the frat house to hook up with a friend, while there freely imbibing more alcohol, smoking marijuana, and snorting ketamine off an erect penis, also allowing four men to snort ketamine off her naked body. 

One of the frat boys sent out a snap-chat telling dozens of others free "pussy" was on offer, which led to the woman having a prolonged group sexual encounter. One of the seven accused is even claiming that HE was sexually assaulted, having been too drunk to give consent. 

Summing up the woman's 2024 statement to police, the Tompkins County District Attorney characterized the sex as "voluntary, conscious, and consensual," (and Jane Doe signed off on the statement under penalty of perjury). On two occasions she had asked the men to stop, and they stopped. In subsequent days she sent text messages saying she had enjoyed the sex and wanted to repeat the first threesome at the fraternity's then upcoming Halloween party. 

However, the accuser's current attorney, hired to pursue a civil action against the accused, says that his client stated in 2024 that she was "100% sure" she had been raped.

Sunny Hostin, current co-host of The View and a former federal sex crimes prosecutor who counts herself among the "believe women" advocates in rape cases, says no prosecutor could have in good conscience pressed charges in the Cornell 7 case. Her statement merits quoting in full:

"I will say that under current New York state law, voluntary intoxication or drug use, and she (the accuser) voluntarily drank a lot, she voluntarily took, snorted ketamine off of one of the boy's body parts . . . she was highly intoxicated, but made plans to meet one of the boys - young men - she allowed other boys and consented to other boys snorting ketamine off of her body, and under New York law voluntary intoxication or drug use that merely impairs judgment does not legally constitute an inability to consent to sexual activity. So that means that if you voluntarily ingest drugs, you voluntarily take alcohol, you can agree to have threesomes, which, in her statement she agreed to have two separate threesomes. One boy did walk in, one young man did walk in and say, "Everybody out." So there was one person that did that, and according to her statement three of the young men did not touch her. And so I say all that, but I say all that, to say the pictures of these young men, who have not been charged, not been adjudicated, are being plastered all over the Internet. I think people are reporting this story inaccurately, I think they're reporting it unfairly. And while this is something that we have to take very seriously, there is no way, according to her statement in 2024, that any prosecutor would have brought forth a case. . . .. According to her statement, she says, they (the Cornell 7) did not attack her - she consented to the sexual activity - she consented to it according to her own statement in 2024. . . .Now I prosecuted sex crimes for ten years. I believe women. I am not saying that we shouldn't believe her, but in 2024 she said one thing, and now in 2026 she is saying another thing."

Those are the facts of the case. The accuser had plans to meet one of the seven accused, voluntarily got high both before and after arriving at the fraternity, never lost consciousness, and agreed to two threesomes, even admitting that three of the seven men never touched her. Under New York law, her decision to voluntarily intoxicate herself does not allow her to avoid responsibility for her subsequent decision to have sex.

A recent New York Times podcast featuring what Malcolm X would have called House Negro commentators (Michelle Cottle, Jamelle Bouie, and David French) passed completely over all this evidence in preference for the thesis that "grab 'em by the pussy" Trump is the main culprit, which theme they went on about at length, with one of them expressing regret that they hadn't even had time to assign proper blame to Jeffrey Epstein.

A familiar Internet mob has formed seeking vengeance, not justice, and predictably, the presumption of innocence and due process of law are nowhere to be found. 

This gives the lie to the claim that the death of "our democracy" is the single-handed achievement of Donald Trump.


Sources:

Glenn Greenwald, "Cornell Students Declared Guilty, Punished By Online Mob Justice,"  System Update, September 30, 2026 (Video clip of Sunny Hostin, co-host of The View, is included in this episode of System Update)

Glenn Greenwald, "New York Times Publishes More Contradictory Evidence on Cornell Case," System Update, October 2, 2026

Dr. Todd Grande, "Cornell Seven Case Raises Double Standard After One Man Says 'Jane Doe' Assaulted Him," You Tube, October 4, 2026

"We Should Be Worried Where The Cornell Case Is Headed," You Tube (New York Times podcast), October 3, 2026




 


Sunday, September 6, 2026

A Quarter-Century After 911: Is It Too Soon To Stop Caricaturing Bin Laden?

How angry America gets when it attacks people and those people resist!

-----------Osama bin Laden, December 1998

How can they hope to be blessed with security while they are dishing out destruction, devastation, and murder on our people in Palestine and Iraq?

-----------Osama bin Laden, December 16, 2004

He dated his political awakening to 1973, when a U.S. airlift helped Israel turn the tide in the so-called Yom Kippur War. Egypt and Syria had overrun Israeli defenses and its vaunted Bar-Lev line at the beginning of the war, leading a stunned Tel Aviv to hint that it might resort to nuclear weapons if the U.S. didn't save the day for the Jewish state. When Washington's intervention helped deal the Arabs another bitter defeat, fifteen-year-old Osama stopped watching cowboy shows, refused to wear Western clothes (except at school, where it was required), and "would sit in front of the television and weep over the news from Palestine." 

The immediate cause of the war was Israeli "development" of the Northeastern Sinai, which involved the forcible removal of Arab farmers from their lands. U.S. support for Israeli annexation of large parts of the Occupied Territories and its refusal to respond to Anwar Sadat's peace overtures, made war inevitable. For bin Laden, it made sympathetic consideration of Western culture impossible.

It was the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982, which killed 20,000 people, overwhelmingly civilians, that planted in bin Laden the seed of revenge. In a November 2004 video he recalled the carnage, the "blood and severed limbs, women and children sprawled everywhere. Houses destroyed along with their occupants and high rises demolished over their residents . . ." He longed to strike back. "As I looked at those destroyed towers in Lebanon, it occurred to me to punish the oppressor in kind by destroying the towers in America, so that it would have a taste of its own medicine and would be prevented from killing our women and children. On that day I became sure that the oppression and intentional murder of innocent women and children is a deliberate American policy."

A decade before the release of this video, bin Laden had been stripped of his Saudi citizenship (1994) for his continued harsh criticism of the Saudi royal family. He wrote a letter to the Chief Mufti, the foremost juridical authority in the Kingdom, calling his endorsement of the 1993 Oslo Accords an "astonishing juridical decree," a betrayal of the word of God and the community of the faithful. Like millions of other Arabs, bin Laden was anguished at the contemptuous treatment Palestinian Arabs continually received at the hands of the West, and saw no reason why it should continue.

Bin Laden's letter argued flat out that the Jews that came to Palestine were not indigenous to the region: "The current Jewish enemy is not an enemy settled in his own original country fighting in its defense until he gains a peace agreement, but an attacking enemy." The only proper course of action, therefore, was to wage jihad, both for the sake of God and "so that Palestine may be completely liberated and returned to Islamic sovereignty." The Oslo Agreement, which nullified Palestinian national rights, converting the PLO to a municipal authority, was a patent fraud: ". . . the alleged peace that the rulers and tyrants are falling over themselves to make with the Jews is nothing but a massive betrayal, epitomized by their signing of the documents of capitulation and surrender of the Holy City of Jerusalem and all of Palestine to the Jews, and their acknowledgement of Jewish sovereignty over Palestine for ever."

In a March, 1997 interview with Robert Fisk of the London Independent, bin Laden again made clear that Israel was a primary grievance. Referring to the Khobar Towers bombing in Saudi Arabia the year before, he said: "The explosion in al-Khobar did not come as a direct reaction to the American occupation, but as a result of American behavior against Muslims, its support of Jews in Palestine and of the massacres of Muslims in Palestine and Lebanon - of Sabra and Chatila and Qana - and of the Sharm el-Sheikh conference." Sabra and Chatila was a 1982 massacre of over a thousand Palestinian refugees by Israel's Phalangist Christian allies in Lebanon; Qana was a U.N. base attacked by Israel in 1996, in which roughly a hundred Lebanese were killed; Sharm el-Sheikh was an "anti-terrorism" conference in which Bill Clinton accused Hamas and Hizbollah of terrorism but said nothing of Israel's far greater terrorism. Events like these merged Israel and the U.S. in bin Laden's mind. "For us there is no difference between the American and Israeli governments or between the American and Israeli soldiers."

Four months after the 1998 attacks on the U.S. Embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, which Bin Laden disclaimed responsibility for, he returned to the theme of the betrayal of Palestine: "Every time a king meets a president they say they have 'discussed the Palestinian issue,' but over half a century a clear picture has emerged: they have abandoned the mujahidin in Palestine. . . they have given a guilty verdict on those lions whose fathers and brothers have been killed, imprisoned, tortured, and persecuted . . . . I don't know what people are waiting for after this clearest of betrayals, and after the shameful way in which the Arab rulers have acted in the interests of the Jews or America."

An interesting side note on the Nairobi Embassy bombing concerns a young Arab questioned by F.B.I. investigator Stephen Gaudin. Identifying himself as Khaled Saleem bin Rasheed from Yemen, he shouted at Gaudin: "You want to blame this (bombing) on me? It's your fault, your country's fault for supporting Israel!" Livid at the death toll, he asked Gaudin: "Why did these people have to die? They had nothing to do with the United States and Israel and Palestine!"

In a statement faxed to Al Jazeera on September 24, 2001, bin Laden excoriated US and Israeli hypocrisy in waxing moralistic on the issue of human rights while it was engaged in wholesale killing in Iraq and Palestine: "Until this point, a million innocent children have been killed in Iraq . . . As I speak, Israeli tanks and bulldozers are going in and wreaking havoc and sin in Palestine - in Jenin, in Ramallah, in Rafah, in Beit Jala . . . . and we do not hear anyone protesting or even lifting a finger to stop it." He insisted on reciprocal security or none at all: "I swear by God Almighty Who raised the heavens without effort that neither America nor anyone who lives there will enjoy safety until safety becomes a reality for us living in Palestine and before all the infidel armies leave the land of Muhammad." The U.S. response came two weeks later, when the White House announced that it had asked the five major U.S. T.V. networks to censor footage of al-Qaeda. National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice "urged all the American network chiefs not to screen videos of Bin Laden."

In a October 21, 2001 interview with Al Jazeera reporter Taysir Alluni in Afghanistan, bin Laden expressed outrage that President Bush and Colin Powell had promised in their first few months in office that "they would move the U.S. embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, and that Jerusalem would be the eternal capital of Israel." Asked about the justification for killing innocent civilians, Bin Laden condemned Washington's selective and self-serving morality: "Whenever we kill their civilians, the whole world yells . . . . and America starts putting pressure on its allies and puppets. . . . What about the people that have been killed in our lands for decades? . . . Who said that our blood isn't blood and that their blood is blood? . . . More than 1,000,000 children died in Iraq, and they are still dying . .. . Everyday in Palestine, children are killed . . . . How is it that these people are moved when civilians die in America, and not when we are being killed everyday?" Near the end of the interview he returned to the constant killing in Palestine: "By what right are our families in Palestine denied safety? The helicopters hunt them while they are in their homes, while they are amongst their women and children; everyday the bodies and wounded are removed."

In an interview published in London's Al Quds on November 12, 2001, bin Laden explained that, "The United States and their allies are killing us in Palestine, Chechnya, Kashmir, and Iraq," so "that's why Muslims have the right to carry out revenge attacks on the U.S.." He added that the democratic nature of the U.S. government implicated all Americans in such crimes. "The American people should remember that they pay taxes to their government and that they voted for their president. Their government makes weapons and provides them to Israel, which they use to kill Palestinian Muslims. Given that the American Congress is a committee that represents the people, the fact that it agrees with the actions of the American government proves that America in its entirety is responsible for the atrocities that it is committing against Muslims. . . . The onus is on Americans to prevent Muslims from being killed at the hands of their government."

In a statement recorded for release to Al Jazeera in December 2001, bin Laden reiterated his claim that the 911 attacks were retaliation for the West's injustices against Muslims worldwide. Once again, he drew attention to Palestine: "Our terrorism against America is a praiseworthy terrorism in defense against the oppressor, in order that America will stop supporting Israel, who kills our sons."

In a letter to the American people on October 6, 2002, bin Laden posed the question, "Why are we fighting and opposing you?" He answered succinctly: "Because you attacked us and continue to attack us." He again drew special attention to Palestine. "The creation and continuation of Israel is one of the greatest crimes, and you are the leaders of its criminals. . . . The creation of Israel is a crime which must be erased . . . The British handed over Palestine, with your help and your support, to the Jews, who have occupied it for more than 50 years, years overflowing with oppression, tyranny, crimes, killing, expulsion, destruction, and devastation." He rejected out of hand tortured Zionist justifications for taking control of the land: "It brings us both laughter and tears to see that you have not yet tired of repeating your fabricated lies that the Jews have a historical right to Palestine, as it was promised to them in the Torah." Debate, he noted, is not tolerated, as "anyone who disputes with them on this alleged fact is accused of anti-semitism." But the Zionist legend claiming justification for Israel "is one of the most fallacious, widely-circulated fabrications in history," since "the people of Palestine are pure Arabs and original Semites." Therefore, "it is the Muslims who are the inheritors of Moses (peace be upon him) and the inheritors of the real Torah that has not been changed," so "if the followers of Moses have been promised a right to Palestine in the Torah, then the Muslims are the most worthy nation of this."

Living under elected government, he went on, "the American people have chosen, consented to, and affirmed their support for Israel's oppression of the Palestinians, the occupation and usurpation of their land, and its continuous killing, torture, punishment, and expulsion of the Palestinians." Better choices exist. "The American people have the ability and choice to refuse the policies of their government, and even to change it if they want."

On the matter of violence, he observed that "If Sharon is a man of peace in the eyes of Bush," which Bush declared he was, "then we are also men of peace. America does not understand the language of manners and principles, so we are addressing it using the language it understands."

In a video dated February 14, 2003, bin Laden warned that "The current Zionist-Crusader campaign . . . is the most dangerous and rabid ever . . . He claimed again that al-Qaeda's violence was merely retaliation, since "we strike them (the U.S.) because of their injustice towards us in the Islamic world, especially in Palestine and Iraq, and their occupation of Saudi Arabia. He observed that the 60 states identified by President Bush as prime targets in his "crusade" against terror pretty much defined the Islamic world. "Is the Islamic world not around 60 states? . . . Did they not say that they want to change the region's ideology, which vents hatred against the Americans?"

In a statement broadcast by Al-Jazeera a month after the Madrid train bombings in 2004 bin Laden accused Washington of "persistently ignor[ing] the real problem, which is the occupation of Palestine," and decried the double standard that allowed U.S. leaders to "indulge in lies and deceit about our right to self-defense," which proved "they have no self-respect." "They show contempt for peoples' blood and minds through such deceit, but it only means that your blood will continue to be shed." 

He was not too blinded by passion to see the injustice being done to ordinary Americans: ". . . an important truth becomes clear, which is that we are both suffering injustice at the hands of your leaders, who send your sons to our countries, despite their objections, to kill and be killed." He identified a common enemy benefitting from all the carnage: "It is all too clear . . . who benefits most from stirring up this war and bloodshed: the merchants of war, the bloodsuckers who direct world policy. . . President Bush . . . the big media . . . the United Nations . . . These and others are groups who are a mortal danger to the entire world, the most dangerous and difficult of these being the Zionist lobby . . ."

Condemning the transparent fraud of Bush's talk of peace, he asked: "Why hasn't he spoken about the one who slit open the bellies of pregnant women in Sabra and Shatila . . . the 'man of peace' [Ariel Sharon]?" He reiterated that al-Qaeda violence was retaliatory: "We only killed Russians after they invaded Afghanistan and Chechnya, we only killed Europeans after they invaded Afghanistan and Iraq, and we only killed Americans after they supported the Jews in Palestine and invaded the Arabian peninsula. . . " 

He offered to make peace with any state that agreed to leave Muslims alone: "So I present to them this peace proposal, which is essentially a commitment to cease operations against any state that pledges not to attack Muslims or intervene in their affairs . . . It will come into effect on the departure of its last soldier from our lands."

Just days before Bush was awarded a second term in November 2004, bin Laden released a video telling the American people that its security was in its own hands, that it could achieve safety by reigning in its lawless government. "We have been fighting you because we are free men who cannot acquiesce in injustice . . . Just as you violate our security, so we violate yours. Whoever encroaches upon the security of others and imagines that he will himself remain safe is but a foolish criminal. When disasters happen, intelligent people look for the reasons behind them, so they can avoid them in the future." 

On March 20, 2008, as Bush's time in office was winding down, Al Jazeera released another video reputed to be from bin Laden, in which he urged holy war on behalf of Palestinians. "Palestine cannot be retaken by negotiations and dialogue, but with fire and iron."

In the eighteen-and-a-half years since that video was released, Barack Obama, Donald Trump, and Joe Biden have striven mightily to make sure the latter statement remains true, escalating from previous U.S.-Israeli policies of episodic mass murder ("mowing the lawn") to what is now widely regarded as wholesale extermination. 

Not surprisingly, the political and historical content of bin Laden's views of U.S. foreign policy has been reflexively dismissed as religious lunacy, on the pretext that perceiving a comprehensible motive  for terrorist attacks against the U.S. is necessarily an act of apologizing for them, and therefore a form of treason. Obviously, the United States always and everywhere promotes only freedom and democracy and human rights, so how could any group of people ever want to deliberately harm us unless they were complete lunatics?

Or so we are encouraged to think. In the immediate aftermath of 911 we were urged by our mind-managers to be alert, not to panic, and to go shopping, purchasing things being the deeply admirable essence of American freedom, and the reason people everywhere allegedly desire to become Americans, over and above any other consideration.

Seen from this quasi-religious perspective, everything makes a perfectly hideous sense. The forever war on Palestine constitutes self-defense against terrorist maniacs; the now clearly failing U.S. effort to sustain repressive Gulf dictatorships committed to burning up an ocean of petroleum to underwrite a suicidally over-consumptive capitalism in the West is tactical realism; and the unprovoked attack on Iran is a vitally necessary continuation of George W. Bush's modest campaign to "rid the world of evil."




The Sources:

"Bin laden accuses pope of 'crusade' in new tape," March 20, 2008 msnbc.com

Bruce Lawrence, ed., "Messages To The World: The Statements of Osama bin Laden" (Verso, 2005) Condoleezza Rice urging censorship of bin Laden on network TV, see p. 112n; Taysir Alluni interview with bin Laden on 10/21/01, see p. 106

Lawrence Wright, "The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11," (Knopf, 2006) Gaudin and the Nairobi Embassy bombing, p. 278

Alfred Lilienthal, "The Zionist Connection - What Price Peace?" (Dodd, Mead, 1978)

Anonymous, "Imperial Hubris - Why The West Is Losing The War on Terror," (Brassey's, 2004)

Robert Fisk, "The Great War For Civilisation - The Conquest of the Middle East," (Knopf, 2005) Impact on bin Laden of the Israeli invasion of Beirut (1982) see p 1033. Sabra and Chatila massacres, attack on Qana and the Sharm-el-Sheikh conference, p. 20

-----Michael K. Smith is the author of "Portraits of Empire" and "The Madness of King George (illustrations by Matt Wuerker,) from Common Courage Press.